Lead Recruiter

About Us

We’re a fast growing, privately held insurance company on a trajectory to scale into a leading U.S. retail platform. As we grow, we're changing how great talent connects with meaningful work to deliver our aggressive strategy while evolving a culture of high performance, creativity, and partnership. If you're energized by building recruiting capability —and love blending strategy with hands-on execution—you’ll thrive here.

About the Role

We’re looking for a Lead Recruiter who brings modern recruiting expertise, a builder’s mindset, and a passion for delivering an exceptional candidate and hiring manager experience. In this role, you’ll lead full cycle recruiting across all functions and levels, while helping to shape our talent acquisition strategy, strengthen our employer brand in the market.

You’ll partner closely with hiring managers, our Chief People Officer and HR Business Partners to find the best talent, build strong networks, improve time to offer, reduce external agency spend, and ensure we’re attracting top talent that aligns with our growth and evolving culture.

What You’ll Do

Lead Full Cycle Recruiting

• Own and manage searches across all departments and all levels, from job intake to offer acceptance partnering with hiring manager and HR business partner
• Write compelling job descriptions and manage postings, screening, interviewing, selection, and offer processes

Drive Talent Pipeline Growth

• Build and nurture ongoing talent pipelines via proactive sourcing, networking, and relationship management
• Partner with universities, professional associations, and industry networks to expand early career and diverse talent pools

Promote Data Driven Recruiting

• Use data and ATS insights to create dashboards, reports, and recommendations that support hiring decisions and workforce planning

Strengthen Employer Brand

• Support the development of recruiting marketing content that showcases our culture, values, candidate and thereby, employee experience
• Champion diverse recruitment initiatives that attract and engage a diverse slate of candidates

Build & Execute Recruiting Strategy

• Help build Prosperity’s talent acquisition strategy while executing in parallel
• Champion and operationalize our ATS (Dayforce Recruiting), ensuring the hiring lifecycle—from requisition intake to offer—runs efficiently and consistently
• Develop innovative sourcing strategies to reach active and passive candidates across the insurance and financial services industry and beyond

What You Bring

Minimum Qualifications

• Bachelor’s degree in Business, HR or related field, or equivalent experience.
• 5–7+ years of candidate sourcing, sales and/or full-cycle recruiting experience.
• Experience in insurance or financial services hiring a plus.
• Strong knowledge of ATS platforms and sourcing tools (Dayforce a plus).
• Proven ability to manage multiple searches simultaneously
• Exceptional communication, relationship building, and influencing skills.

Preferred Qualifications

• Experience in high growth, high volume, and/or small company environments.
• Experience driving strategic-based hiring while managing ongoing recruitment needs.

Core Competencies

• Execution Excellence: Balances speed and quality while managing multiple roles.
• Candidate Focus: Delivers an inclusive, engaging, and respectful experience.
• Communication: Clear, timely, and persuasive with candidates and leaders.
• Data Literacy: Uses metrics to inform decisions and improve performance.
• Independence: Operates autonomously with sound judgement, driving recruiting outcomes to deliver high-quality, timely results.
• Adaptability: Thrives in a dynamic, growing company.
• Strategic Thinking: Aligns hiring priorities with business needs.